How to Choose Where to Stay: Reading Reviews, Locations and the Small Print
Location beats everything, and the review score is the least useful number on the page.
6 min read
—Not yet rated
Loading…
Location beats everything, and the review score is the least useful number on the page.
Everyone has stayed somewhere that looked excellent online and turned out to be forty minutes from anything, on a main road, with a bathroom the photographs had carefully avoided.
Booking platforms are optimised to make everything look reasonable, and the headline review score — the number most people sort by — hides more than it reveals.
Reading a listing properly takes about five minutes and is the difference between accommodation that supports a trip and accommodation you spend the trip working around.
This is the single most common mistake. Somewhere twenty per cent cheaper but thirty minutes out of the centre costs you the difference in transport, and much more in time and willingness to go out again after dinner.
Before booking, do two checks. Put the address into a map and look at walking times to the places you actually intend to visit, not the distance in kilometres, which ignores hills, rivers and motorways. Then switch to street view and look at the road it is on — a hotel can be central and still sit on a six-lane road with no crossing.
For city trips, a smaller room in a good location beats a larger one further out almost every time. The room is where you sleep; the location is where you spend the trip.
The overall score is close to useless because it aggregates everything. A place with a 9.1 might have superb staff and a persistent noise problem, and the number tells you neither.
Listed rates frequently exclude a great deal. Cleaning fees on short apartment stays can be a large proportion of the total, city taxes are often added at checkout or on arrival, resort fees exist mainly to keep headline prices low, and parking and breakfast are commonly separate.
| Charge | Where it appears | How to handle it |
|---|---|---|
| Cleaning fee | at checkout, flat rate | punishes short stays; compare per-night totals |
| City or tourist tax | sometimes paid on arrival | budget for it; it varies by city |
| Resort fee | at checkout or on arrival | check what it includes; often nothing you want |
| Parking | usually separate | can exceed the room rate in city centres |
| Breakfast | optional extra | frequently cheaper at a café nearby |
| Card or currency fees | at payment | pay in local currency, always |
Take every option to the final payment screen before comparing. Two listings that appear thirty pounds apart routinely finish level or reversed once fees, taxes and parking are included. It is the only honest comparison.
Listing photographs are chosen, edited and often taken with a wide lens that makes rooms look considerably larger than they are. What they conceal is fairly consistent.
The remedy is street view for the exterior and surroundings, recent guest photographs where the platform shows them, and reading the room description properly rather than looking at pictures.
The right kind of accommodation depends more on the trip's shape than on budget.
For a one or two-night city stop, a well-located hotel or guesthouse wins — check-in is simple, there is someone at a desk, and you are not managing a property. For a week in one place with a family, an apartment with a kitchen and a washing machine usually wins comfortably. For rural trips, a guesthouse with dinner available saves an evening drive that nobody enjoys after a day outdoors.
When budget allows a step up, spend it in a specific order.
A couple booked a four-night city stay at a place forty pounds a night below the alternatives, about four kilometres from the centre, with a 9.2 review score.
The score was accurate about the staff, who were excellent. It did not convey that the walk into town was fifty minutes, that the nearest metro was a twenty-minute walk, or that returning after dinner meant a taxi.
Four nights of taxis and metro tickets came to more than the saving, and they twice ended an evening early rather than face the journey back. The better-located option would have been cheaper and better.
Book through the property's own site or a well-established platform, and be wary of unusually cheap listings that ask for payment by bank transfer or outside the platform. Accommodation scams are common in high-demand periods, and paying outside a platform removes every protection it offers.
Judge location by walking times and street view rather than by distance. Ignore the headline score and read recent negative reviews for patterns. Compare fully inclusive totals. Distrust photographs and check room size and the bathroom. Match the accommodation type to the trip, and spend extra on location, quiet and sleep.
Accommodation is one of the few travel decisions that affects every single day of a trip, and it is routinely made in four minutes by sorting a list by price.
Give it fifteen instead. It is the highest return on time in the whole planning process. For deciding where to go in the first place, see our guide to travelling on a small budget.
Tap a star to share what you thought.
No ratings yet
Location, by a wide margin. It affects every day of your trip, while the room affects mainly the hours you are asleep. Check walking times to the places you actually plan to visit rather than straight-line distance.
Ignore the headline score, sort by most recent, and read the negative reviews from the last three months looking for repeated themes. One complaint about noise is an individual; six is a characteristic of the building.
Cleaning fees, city or tourist taxes, resort fees, parking and breakfast are frequently excluded from the headline rate. Take every option through to the final payment screen before comparing, since the ranking often changes.
The view from the window, the true room size, the bathroom if it is poor, the absence of a lift, and the fact that the photographed room is usually the best in its category. Street view and the stated square metres are more reliable.
It depends on the trip. Hotels and guesthouses suit short city stops where simple check-in matters. Apartments with a kitchen and laundry suit longer stays and families. Rural trips often benefit from somewhere that serves dinner.
Book through the property's own website or an established platform, and treat requests to pay by bank transfer or outside the platform as a serious warning sign. Unusually cheap listings in high-demand periods deserve particular scepticism.
Sign in to join the conversation.
Loading responses…
Have a story, idea, or something valuable to share? Join The Blog Story for free, publish your content, reach more readers, and earn a share of advertising revenue from eligible content.
Create quality content. Grow your audience. Grow your earning potential.